Skip to content
120 Liberty Street
(848) 305-9945

If your basement regularly floods, a sump pump is a good way to deal with the water. Like all mechanical devices, sump pumps will occasionally have issues. Here are some troubleshooting steps to consider to help diagnose why your sump isn’t working correctly.

Power Outages

One frustrating problem with your sump pump is when it won’t turn on. Your sump pump is typically wired to your home electrical system. If this is your only power source for the sump, then it won’t work during power outages. Ironically, these are often caused by the same storms that require your sump to work. This can be dealt with in two ways. If you have a whole-home generator for power outages, then ensure your sump is connected to the generator grid. If you don’t, many sumps come with battery backup systems to allow them to operate for short periods when the power is offline.

Clogged Discharge Line

One particularly frustrating issue you may experience with your sump pump is that there’s no water coming out of the discharge pipe. If your pump is not actively sucking water, look for a clog somewhere in your discharge line. This isn’t uncommon, as dirt and other debris from your basement floor can get into the pit and be sucked up into your pump. The discharge line can be unclogged with a drain snake or a high-pressure burst of water.

Frozen Discharge Line

For your sump pump to adequately do its job, it should be moving water from your basement to a location outside, away from your home’s foundation. During colder temperatures, it’s not uncommon for water to freeze in the discharge line if it’s not adequately protected. Unfortunately, when your line is frozen, it’s unable to remove water from your basement. You’ll need to unfreeze your discharge line to get it working again. To prevent this issue from happening in the first place, it’s a good idea to make sure your drainage lines are well insulated or buried below the frost line.

Broken Check Valve

If you look at the way your sump pump plumbing is designed, you’ll notice that the discharge line will flow up against gravity to the outside of your home. While the force of the pump can help to push out about one-third to two-thirds of the water in the discharge line, it still needs extra help to prevent water from backflowing into the pit. It gets this help from a check valve. If you notice that your sump pump is removing some water from the discharge line but not a whole lot, your check valve may need replacement.

Float Switch Issues

A vital component of your sump pump is its float switch, which sits on the side of the pump. As the water level rises in the basin, the float switch is naturally pushed up. This tells the sump to turn on. When the switch goes up, your sump pump turns on. Once it pumps all the water out to the level where your float switch is set, the float goes back down, turning the sump pump off.

If you notice a lot of water sitting in your basin and your sump pump isn’t turning on, then your float switch may be set too high. Conversely, if you notice that your sump pump is running often while the water level is very low, your float switch may be set too low.

A very common problem that people experience with their float switch is that it gets stuck in one position or the other. Whenever you’re switch gets stuck, it can keep your pump in the on or off position. Typically, removing whatever debris is stuck up against the float switch will help to allow it to go back to function like normal. If removing debris doesn’t work, then it’s likely the float switch has failed.

Motor Problems

At the very core of your sump pump is its motor. This motor provides power to the impeller to move water. If your sump pump simply won’t turn on and you’ve rolled out a power issue, then it’s most likely that the motor is the issue. If your sump pump is 10 to 15 years old, your motor has likely reached the end of its lifespan. However, if your sump pump is fairly new, there may be a malfunction. Have a professional assess the motor to determine the component so that it can be replaced or repaired.

Clogged Intake Screen

If you examine your sump pump, you’ll be able to find a mesh screen that covers the location where water is pulled into your pump. The screen is designed to help prevent unwanted debris from entering your pump and causing damage. Unfortunately, there can be a lot of debris in the water that your pump is trying to suck up, which can clog the mesh screen. Fortunately, this can be easily fixed by removing the debris from the mesh screen so that water can freely flow into the pump.

Impeller Issues

Another essential component of your sump pump is its impeller. This is a fan-like device that works to force water in the appropriate direction so that it can be pumped out of the basin. If you start to hear rattling, grinding, or other similar noises coming from your sump pump, it’s typically an indication there is a problem with its impeller. The impeller blades can be damaged or jammed with debris. It’s typically best to call in a plumbing professional to assess the issue and remedy it.

Undersized Pump

For a sump pump to be effective at removing water from your basement, it needs to be appropriately sized. The necessary size for your sump pump is going to depend on several factors. Some of these include the type of soil that your home sits on, the size of your basement, the size of the piping used, the vertical discharge height, and so much more. If you’ve recently had a sump pump installed and it isn’t adequately removing the water from your basement, you likely have an undersized pump. Unfortunately, the only solution here is to replace the pump with a bigger one that better fits your needs.

Smart Sumps

Newer sumps may come with a smart monitoring system. These systems can help you to detect issues without the need to spend all your time in the basement. Smart sumps can track the frequency and volume of water that the pump is moving. They will tell you when the power is out, also. This can give you an idea of when the sump is running too much or not often enough.

Reliable Sump Pump Service

First Choice Plumbing, Heating, Air Conditioning & Electrical offers reliable sump pump service for the entire Metuchen, NJ region. We can also assist with all of your heating, cooling, oil-to-gas conversion, commercial, indoor air quality, and plumbing needs. Give us a call to schedule your next service appointment today.

superhero banner

24/7 Emergency Service
What They're Saying
Customer Reviews

Dave and Eli from First Choice did an excellent job installing a toilet in my home. They arrived on time, were professional and clean, and completed the work quickly with top-quality results. Highly recommend!

Gvido T

A service person named Angel quickly diagnosed and fixed the issue with my AC. He was very professional. I was so happy with the experience that I signed up for a yearly maintenance contract. I found First Choice based on good local Facebook feedback and I am so glad that I did!

Ann Marie Regan

Had a plumbing, piece of water brass pipe replaced under deck and valve installed. Eli was great in giving few different options and suggestions for best method. I was very
happy with same day service and work.

Rupal B

The First Choice techs are always great but Angel was particularly outstanding today. He did a very thorough maintenance and cleaning check. He was super patient with all of my questions and really helped us plan out preventative maintenance on our system. Highly recommend Angel and First Choice!

Cassandra S

We had 2 new hvac systems and a hot water heater replaced and WOW cannot say enough good things about all 4 guys that did the work. Efficient, caring, knowledgeable and all professional. We highly recommend First Choice, from our initial meeting with Ryan to the completion of the installation. Thank you for a perfect job!

Debbie D

First Choice came out today for my annual A/C maintenance, and I couldn’t be more pleased with the experience. Lenny Z was the technician — he was professional, courteous, and right on time. He made sure everything was running efficiently before he left. I highly recommend First Choice for anyone looking for reliable, top-notch service for their HVAC !

Howard Z

5 Stars! We had a fantastic experience with First Choice. They installed two new HVAC systems for our business, and the team of Jeff, Ethan, and Joey was professional, efficient, and great to work with. Highly recommend!

Eddie M

I had a leaking toilet and gave First Choice a call. They responded quickly and sent someone out the same day. Jordan was very professional, diagnosed the problem right away, and fixed it without any hassle. The leak is gone, and everything works perfectly now. Highly recommend!

Joan

I had my annual maintenance today for my boiler and mini splits and couldn’t be happier with the service. Angel Garcia from First Choice Plumbing and HVAC went above and beyond. He was patient when I asked questions, very thorough, and took great care of everything like it was his own home. You can tell he truly loves what he does, and that the company really values its people. Highly recommend Angel and the First Choice team!

Chris R

I have depended upon First Choice for several years to address all my heating and cooling needs and have never been disappointed
Techs have always been knowledgeable and technically competent, in addition to which
courteous and respectful.
I would prefer my heating and cooling needs to be minor but at least I am comforted by knowing this company is always prepared to handle any issue which this household may face, thus I highly recommend First Choice

John M

First Choice heating & cooling sent a very professional repair man named Angel who did an amazing job doing some electrical work to get my A/C unit working late on a Friday evening. He responded within hours and got the A/C up and running on this super hot day. Thank you Angel from First Choice in Metuchen, NJ! I highly recommend them!

Doris Cruz

Angel came for a complimentary service after a new HVAC was installed this past winter. Angel was extremely helpful and informative. Was at the house for about an hour showing me different ways to have better airflow and also switched out filters. Would highly recommend !!

Joseph G

Angel Garcia is the best!!! First Choice has just been great about upgrading my systems. They are neat and their work is impeccable and very pretty. I have used them since 1987 and have no complaints. Angel has been wonderful about making sure we have what we need. He feels like my personal consultant, but all the folks there are so helpful and responsive. Highly highly recommend them.

Barbara M

We had Alex Dicrosta of First Choice come check our furnace today because it was leaking water when the AC was on. Alex diagnosed the issue quickly that it was a clogged pipe going from the water pump. He unclogged the pipe and confirmed that was the cause of the leak. Alex is extreme knowledgeable, friendly, and customer focused. He even checked the rest of the unit to make sure everything was working properly before he left. I will definitely request Alex the next time I need AC or heating service from First Choice.

Rich R